Mental illness is shrouded in myth. The silence surrounding psychiatric distress has left these conditions to exist largely in shadow, fuelling stigmas and shame. So when The New York Times published “Patient Voices: Bipolar Disorder” to demystify the lived experiences of those living with bipolar disorder, the premise was promising. The stories, told by five men and women diagnosed with bipolar disorder, tell tales of extreme manias manifesting in outlandish grandiosity, wild spending sprees, and psychosis . The narratives are harrowing and they are moving, giving voice to the deep pain, disorientation, and dysfunction that so often plague those with bipolar illness.
But the narratives are also limited in scope and in many ways conform to what we expect bipolar disorder to look like—after all, what could suggest bipolar disorder more than a woman running naked down the street to meet God? We do not find the voice of those whose bipolar disorder includes no mania at all, but is defined primarily by deep depressive episodes punctuated only by the temporary elevation of hypomania. We do not find the voice of those whose bipolar disorder manifests in the oscillating and enduring hypomanic and depressive symptoms of cyclothymia, never crossing the threshold into fully diagnosable states. Nor do we find the stories of those whose bipolar symptoms cannot be adequately captured in an existing classification and are therefore described as “other specified bipolar.”
The absence of these stories is in many ways understandable; it took until 1994 for the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) to differentiate between bipolar I and bipolar II, and the distinction is still trickling its way down into public consciousness. But recognizing the heterogeneity of bipolar disorder is critical to validating the varied experiences of those struggling with these complicated illnesses and understanding the need for individualized bipolar disorder treatment.



