In 2008, something extraordinary happened: the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA). No longer would mental illness be treated differently than physical illnesses. No longer would people be denied treatment—explicitly or in effect—because their ailment appeared in the mind rather than the body. No longer would people have to suffer needlessly. Right? Well, not exactly. Although the MHPAEA was indeed something to celebrate, it wasn’t everything we had hoped, all because of just two words: medically necessary.
While “medically necessary” is indeed the standard by which most treatment of physical afflictions is also approved or denied, making mental illnesses ostensibly on par with other ailments, the nature of mental illness itself creates an enormous loophole for insurers. As psychologist Darcy Lockman writes in an illuminating article for Slate, “I believe that my work always falls comfortably within the range of medical necessity. Given the ambiguity of the language and the fact that problems in living cannot yet be biopsied, it is all but impossible to debate anyone who simply declares it does not.” Ostensible lack of medical necessity can be used to justify the denial of everything from a basic course of CBT to last-resort ECT treatment. And even when some form of treatment is covered, it is often limited in scope, keeping patients from receiving the care they need for true healing. This is particularly true when it comes to residential care.



