In recent years, mental illness has become more visible in public discourse than perhaps ever before. Unfortunately, many of these conversations have taken place in the aftermath of mass shootings and other horrific violent crimes. Headlines like “Allowing the Mentally Ill Guns Is Insane,” “Madman Kills Nine,” “James Holmes Saw Three Mental Health Professionals Before Shooting,” and “Newtown Massacre Result of Mental Illness, Access to Guns, Death Obsession” adorn the covers of newspapers, bolstering already-dangerous cultural assumptions about mental illness and violence and further marginalizing those living with mental health disorders. A Washington Post-ABC News poll published last fall reveals that a full 63% of respondents identify mental health problems as the primary cause of mass shootings. For many, simply the act of committing a sensationally violent crime is thought to be proof enough that someone is suffering from a mental illness, a belief rooted in the tautological reasoning that mental stability precludes such violent acts.
The effect of this public association between psychiatric illness and violent criminal acts is more than just hypothetical and nebulous stigma; the Helping Families in Mental Health Crisis Act of 2015, federal legislation that allows for “the removal of privacy protections, forced institutionalization, and compelled compliance to drug regimes,” has been introduced in the aftermath of recent mass shootings. Predicated on the widely-held belief that mental illness is directly responsible for these crimes, the act is considered by many mental health advocacy groups to be a dangerous threat to the civil liberties of people living with mental health disorders. As an article in the American Journal of Public Health points out, in this environment, “’mentally ill’ ceases to be a medical designation and becomes a sign of violent threat.”



