For people suffering from depression, any type of exercise can confer meaningful benefits and contribute to a sense of well-being, self-esteem, and self-determination. However, if the goal is specifically hippocampal neurogenesis, some forms of exercise appear to be better than others. In a study published last month in The Journal of Physiology, researchers at the University of Jyvaskyla in Finland divided rats into two groups, one of which engaged in exercise and the other remaining sedentary. The exercising rats were further divided into subgroups according to type of exercise, including voluntary running, resistance training, and high-intensity interval training involving fast-paced running. After seven weeks, the researchers examined the hippocampal tissue of each subject and discovered great differences in neurogenesis between each group of rats, “suggest[ing] that physical exercise promotes adult hippocampal neurogenesis most effectively if the exercise is aerobic and sustained.” Gretchen Reynolds of The New York Times explains:
Those rats that had jogged on wheels showed robust levels of neurogenesis. Their hippocampal tissue teemed with new neurons, far more than in the brains of the sedentary animals. There were far fewer new neurons in the brains of the animals that had completed high-intensity interval training. They showed somewhat higher amounts than in the sedentary animals but far less than in the distance runners. And the weight-training rats […] showed no discernible augmentation of neurogenesis. Their hippocampal tissue looked just like that of the animals that had not exercised at all.
Thus far, the exact cause of these differences is not entirely known, but authors of the study believe that long-distance running may stimulate the production of BDNF, causing new neurons and synapses to grow. In fact, the level of BDNF found in the rats’ brains was directly proportional the distances they ran. Meanwhile, the lack of benefits afforded by high-intensity interval training may be due to the physiological and psychological stress of the exercise itself. Dr. Miriam Nokia, lead author on the study, notes that, “Stress tends to decrease adult hippocampal neurogenesis.”
This does not mean that people with depression should only engage in sustained aerobic exercise; there are real physical and emotional benefits to many forms of exercise, and the best exercise regime is one you will stick to. Incorporating activities that promote hippocampal neurogenesis within a well-rounded physical fitness program, however, may help you guard against and reverse deterioration of this vital area of the brain.